Question:
Who here has finished reading Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows? NO SPOILERS?
hotmama
2007-07-22 06:40:47 UTC
I finished it yesterday and it was amazing!
I give it 10/10 JK Rowling done a fantastic job =)
Your ratings?
26 answers:
2007-07-22 06:43:23 UTC
3/10
2014-09-16 07:52:26 UTC
Hello,

I found a free download of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows game here: http://bitly.com/1qXE85s



it's the full version, avaiable for free! very fast to install

At the start of the game, the player is already on the run as he battles for survival. He needs to accomplish a frantic and risky mission of finding the location and wiping out Voldemort's Horcruxes.

It's a very nice game.
2007-07-25 05:57:00 UTC
I read an ebook version. Probably have permanetly damaged my eyes. But I'm not going to pay $30 bucks for a book I'll read once. Anywho, I thought it was good, but over rated. The plot / reasoning felt thinly held together. There were just so many contradictions. Also, I noticed some continuity errors. (spoiler alert- i like to support claims) E.g., Hermione says she has never cast a memory charm before and only knows the theory..but this can't be true, as she wiped the memory of her parents. I felt the ending was cliche. Characters died needlessly. The story basically involved death- harry getting over the death and then someone dies again. endless cycle. And then they all have children...bah. I understand though..it would have been a hard book to write.
Avondrow
2007-07-22 07:00:12 UTC
She has done a remarkable job of pulling all the threads together in an emotionally fulfilling climax.



But I do question the extent to which it can be described as a children's book. Some of the fans waiting to buy their copy looked very young. I mean, it begins with a quote from Aeschylus, for goodness sake.



Personally, I have to give it 10/10
Daisy the cow
2007-07-22 09:14:24 UTC
Yes, I finished it yesterday too. I loved it. Couldn't have asked for a better story to finish the series. The plot was gripping, I found every page leaving me wanting more. I was sad about the characters who died (don't want to put the names in for those who haven't read it!!!), but on the whole the book was balanced well.
♥Rae♥
2007-07-22 07:00:35 UTC
I finished it yesterday at 11:12 after starting it at 3:15. I will admit it took me longer because yes. I am only twelve. I give the book a 10/10 but the epuloge kinda ruined part of the seven books
Carrie
2007-07-22 07:33:53 UTC
I would give it 10/10, amazing!!

Although I had trouble reading the last few chapters as I was crying so much! It reduced me to a wreck!!



And althoughv most people are saying that the epilogue was really bad, I loved it and thought it was the perfect ending to the series.
Barbiq
2007-07-22 07:02:20 UTC
I finished it late last night....it was amazing and after I take a nap I will begin to read it again, more slowly this time. I loved the way she tied so much together and gave us a time frame for this book and for the series....and she really did end it all well. :)



If you haven't gotten to the end make sure you have your tissue box handy!! Personally, I give it a 9/10
Sam W
2007-07-22 08:49:50 UTC
Definately a 10/10. I thought it was absolutely spectacular!! Gripping and emotional. I'm still crying about it now and I finished it about 11am. Already started reading it again.

I think people of all ages should read HP. I'm 27 and love it, along with my 14 year old sister & my dad. People who don't read them just really can't understand why we all love it soooo much.

I thought JK did a really great job, and I was just glad all along that I was right about Snape!
2007-07-24 08:52:08 UTC
OMG.... the best!!!!!! the climax, the plot, the drama!!! i liked it so much!!! and the epilogue was touching. i have to say, i felt satisfied when i finished reading, but at the same time it was sad. not only will there never be another harry potter books, but lots of good characters dies! i've been following harry since i was young, and i have to say, i don't think i'll ever forget him. 10/10



oh, and massage to the spoilers. stay out of my life... if i have one. :)
2007-07-22 06:57:47 UTC
10/10...the very last bit was a teensy bit predictable, I think most of us guessed that's how it would end but I still loved it. it was a perfect way to wrap things up. I totally agree, she did do a fantastic job. there was great twists throughout the book. I loved it, couldn't put it down =)
2016-10-09 09:53:52 UTC
i did no longer anticipate Harry to die. there have been countless "what i think of ought to ensue" essays interior the interior of reach paper each week previously the launch of the e book. considered one of them via a 14-year-previous female that became remarkably properly completed (her father works for the paper), or perhaps predicted that Harry became the seventh horcrux and can could desire to die. Remarkably she have been given one million/2 of it appropriate. What I did anticipate and it appeared for the longest time to be suited, became that Snape had hoodwinked Dumbledore the entire time; yet he hadn't. usual, i think of it became properly completed. there are various of little issues that are perhaps edited out or we would have one thousand pages, yet i think of it comes out because it desires to. it particularly is the story of Harry (and Ron and Hermione) getting to comprehend the thank you to handle destroying the horcruxes and defeating Voldemort. alongside the way they arrive to discover the story of the Deathly Hallows besides. so as that it leaves out different issues is comprehensible. Of all the storylines that have been closed off, to me there became one obvious omission: the Dursleys. They went off for magical risk-free practices, yet we on no account heard how they fared. i presumed she could have fastened them up somewhat actual. something like Harry could have ran into (met) Dudley at King's pass while he became taking his teenagers to get the Hogwarts show. they could have had a short communication or something. perhaps one that exposed that Dudley nevertheless favored Harry for saving him from the Dementors inspite of each little thing the years? perhaps Harry ought to civilly ask how his aunt and uncle have been doing? it ought to have been an extremely short factor; some sentences at maximum.
Hana
2007-07-22 06:55:21 UTC
I pulled an all-nighter to read it... my goodness, it really was something.

I felt like reading (albeit well-written) fanfiction. Though it was incredible in some parts (lots, really), there were certain bits that i felt was unnecessary (thus the fanfic feel). Nevertheless, it's an exhilirating read. Very emotional, very grabbing.



I'd give it a 9/10
Mickster
2007-07-22 06:54:30 UTC
i didnt read it, lost interest after the 5th - ironically i read the first before it was even heard about.



But my girlfriend spent the whole of yesterday reading it and then walked me through it. sounded alright if a little too rounded at the end, i mean i personally prefer books that leave you in wonder but by the sounds of things this one tired up every loose end.
?
2007-07-22 08:21:06 UTC
5 out of 10 [I think potter is overrated too. Sorry.]



I thought it was good in the beginning.

The deaths didn't bother me. Except for Dobby's. I like Dobby.



It had a big deux ex machina, somewhat cheesy ending. Not for me. Then again, I'm a cynic-pessimist.
2007-07-23 14:43:20 UTC
I have just finished it, it was really good now i,m going to read all 7 books again in order.
junglejungle
2007-07-22 06:51:45 UTC
i don't understand why people were is a major hurry to read it



in the sense of.. if you have an amazing meal you want to savour the taste..



perhaps she did an amazing job, but what are potter fans gonna do now they completed the book so fast?!?! =)
jbenishmlt
2007-07-22 06:48:47 UTC
9 out of 10. I had a few other choices for ppl to die. could of just swapped some of the characters out.
PatsLax39
2007-07-22 06:45:31 UTC
i bought it yesterday at like two o'clock in the afternoon and i never got around to reading it so i'll read it today



im sure its atleast 9/10
v
2007-07-22 07:22:55 UTC
i have yeah it was really good probably 9/10 cos that last few pages sucked
T Delfino
2007-07-22 07:52:58 UTC
Yep, i thought it was brilliant! 9.7/10 for me
2007-07-22 07:06:49 UTC
did cho chang used to lay quidditch cuz i got this game nd it says chang
mike&rach
2007-07-25 02:33:28 UTC
Excellent.

Snapes story was heart rending?
2007-07-22 10:12:48 UTC
i agree withu

10/10

i couldn't put it down! i stayed awake til 4 this morning reading it!
You think you know me?
2007-07-22 06:50:12 UTC
i not yet read the book, but i read the summary in wikipedia and i find it amazing!!!!



just sad that its going to end u noe...



god ron and hermoine!!



but i stil dont understand why harry will end up with gina weisley??



i prefer him with that chinese chick, i think her name is cho??



what do u think guys??
2007-07-22 06:45:35 UTC
God! I can't believe he's dead!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...