Question:
Percy Jackson or Harry Potter?
Nambi Paramanandam
2011-10-22 05:19:51 UTC
1. Harry Potter or Percy Jackson?
The wizard or the demigod. I go with Percy.
2. Ron or Grover?
The red haired boy or the satyr. I go with Grover.
3.Hermione or Annabeth?
One of the best wizards or the daughter of Athena, the goddess of Wisdom. I go with Annabeth.
4.Voldemort or Kronos?
He who must not be named(hey, I think that's also a name) or the Lord of Time? Kronos is my choice.
5.Draco or Luke?
The cunning Slytherin or the host of Kronos? Tie.
6. The Battle of Hogwarts or the Battle of Manhattan?
I am with Battle of Manhattan?

Finally...
7. J.K.R. or Rick Riordan?
Seventeen answers:
anonymous
2011-10-22 10:05:54 UTC
1. Harry Potter or Percy Jackson?

Percy Jackson. Sorry, but Percy has way more personality than Harry ever did. Percy cracks jokes, gets scared, and fights for what he believes in but he still acts his age. Harry is kind of boring when you think of it. What does he have going for his personality? That he's The Boy Who Lived? Percy is just a lot more interesting and fun to read about.

2. Ron or Grover?

Grover for sure. I just love his sweet, timid and shy personality and he's pretty funny too. I've fallen in love with Grover and Ron just doesn't do it for me. He acts moody and selfish most of the time and he basically ditched Harry and Hermione once in DH.

3.Hermione or Annabeth?

ANNABETH!! Oh my gods I love Annabeth. She's my favorite character. She's smart, intelligent, sarcastic, witty, but she also has her flaws too (we've seen that in SOM) but Hermione is only book smart and acts snobby most of the time. So Annabeth is my obvious choice.

4.Voldemort or Kronos?

I'm going to have to go with Kronos. He seems much more scarier to me than Voldemort. I've never been able to be truly scared of You-Know-Who, but there's just something about Kronos... I mean, he ate his own kids!

5.Draco or Luke?

Draco. I know I'm going to be pretty hypocritical on this one but I've just never liked Luke. I love Draco and I feel for him. His dad was never there and he wanted to make them proud but in the end he had no way out of it. I feel if he had better parents he wouldn't have done the things he did. Luke on the other hand just annoys me.

6. The Battle of Hogwarts or the Battle of Manhattan?

Can I cheat and say both for this one? The Battle of Hogwarts was so crazy and exciting and all that good stuff, but so was Battle of Manhattan. I was freaking out when Annabeth got stabbed but with all the deaths and stuff going on with the Battle of Hogwarts I was pretty much crying! I don't know, I think they were both amazing parts to read, so I'll say tie.

7. J.K.R. or Rick Riordan?

Rick Riordan. He's improved and it's definitely showing as each book goes on and he just seems to know how to write for the audience he is aiming for better than J.K. does. Plus, you just have to love that guy, he's so funny and nice :D



Also can I just say some of you guys are being really immature with your answers? ;___; And let me just say PJO is NOT a copy of HP. J.K. didn't invent all of that stuff she just used it and everyone else has the right to use it in their books too. Deal with it :)
Unique4Eva256
2014-05-10 15:21:27 UTC
I am not ranting of trying to be bitter but, almost everyone says Annabeth beats Hermione because she's the daughter of wisdom or whatever. But u ppl don't think abt this, Hermione was muggle born she wasn't famous like Annabeth. Her parents weren't even wizards! They were dentists and she may be booksmart and not that strong but look at it this way, hermione sacrificed her parents for their safety. What did Annabeth do? And yes I agree that hermione wasn't witty strong and brave, but I think hermione's traits are more relateable than annabeth' sand that's just my OPINION
anonymous
2011-10-22 08:03:00 UTC
1: Percy Jackson.

2: Grover, because he's awesome and Ron gets on my nerves sometimes.

3: Annabeth.

4: Voldemort, because I think he's a bigger threat than Kronos is.

5: Draco.

6: The Battle of Manhattan

7: Rick Riordan
Katie
2015-08-04 08:39:34 UTC
1. Percy. He just seems so much more human to me.

2. Grover. Ron can get on my nerves.

3. Hermione.

4. Kronos. Voldemort isn't all that scary.

5. Draco.

6. Both!

7. Uncle Rick. He is awesome! And did not copy HP.

Let it be known, I love both. But as I tell my friends, I thought I was obsessed with HP. Then I read PJO and HoO and knew I never cared about HP.
The Grim
2011-10-22 08:23:33 UTC
Harry Potter

Ron Weasley

Hermione granger

Voldemort

Draco

Battle of Hogwarts (Battle of Manhattan?! Seriously?!)

J.K. (She's magical and makes the text come alive <3 )



Plus! Like it or not, PJO IS in many ways a copy of HP. Flying shoes? Secret elevators? Mysterious passages leading to a different world? Magical creatures?

Come on, you can't deny it.



Seaweed Brain - I disagree with your last answer's reason. You said J.K. stopped writing because she was greedy? If she were greedy she would've kept on writing and giving the people what they wanted and earning lots of money. Most authors keep writing books and stories so they can publish them, become famous and rich. I don't see that happening with J.K. And when you read her books and other facts on Pottermore etc you can just tell how much she loves her work and characters. Also, she made sure that the entire cast of Harry Potter was English because she wanted to help the British economy and wanted the world to know how talented English people are. She refused sums of money she was offered to expand the cast. So all I'm saying is check up on your facts before making accusations against great people. I have nothing against Rick Riordan and I think he's a great author but...



SORRY! CAN'T HEAR YOU OVER THE SOUND OF OUR HARRY POTTER AMUSEMENT PARK!!

:D
Sεαѡεεɖ ɓɾɑіɳ
2011-10-22 05:44:27 UTC
Percy Jackson

I can relate to Percy more than Harry. Harry is cool but Percy is more of a hero. He has faults while Harry was just too perfect (Having no family is not a fault) Percy even had a break down in the newest book. Harry just shouted and to me, that was like very immature and childish.



Grover

Grover had been caring for Percy for a full year before Percy even knew. Grover is the bravest Satyr in the world. He overcome all his fears just to follow Percy to the Underworld and that took guts! Ron just left when things got bad



Annabeth

Hermione is clever, but it is just book clever. In the real world she isn’t that intelligent. Annabeth is the daughter of a Wisdom Goddess, she is wise as well as intelligent so there is no contest. Annabeth wins



Kronos

He is a Titan, not even the gods could stop him. Look at how many demigods and gods he brainwashed into joining him. Luke was a great hero until Kronos got to him and look what happened to Luke



Luke

Luke is my hero, In book one when he helped Percy was nice of him, even if he was working for Kronos at the time. In book 5 when we see what Luke was like before Kronos got into his head. Luke was so brave but he had a vulnerability to him, when we saw him crying over Hermes not being there for him when he needed him most was really heart wrenching and we all know Luke only went to Kronos because he thought the gods didn’t care about him. Luke did the right thing in the end, he turned on Kronos even though it killed him and what is why I think Luke is better than Draco. Draco did it just because his daddy did it and then he didn’t even do anything good in the end. Luke gave his life to set things right



Battle of Hogwarts

I liked how everyone came together to save Hogwarts, it was great to see all the Death Eaters and Giants trying to destroy the place and of course Harry walking off into the forest and Snape and the memories were fantastic! The Battle of Manhattan was good too, I was so scared when Ethan stabbed Annabeth and when Percy was with Kronos on that bridge, but I think the battle at Hogwarts was bigger. Most of the best things at the Battle of Manhattan was done on Olympus where Percy and Luke/Kronos had their final fight and Luke ended it :’(



Rick Riordan

I think Rick Riordan is by far the better writer. Jk Rowling may be worth more money but J.K.Rowling is very lazy and greedy with money. She has only ever written Harry potter and when that got her money, she stopped writing. She hasn’t wrote anything for years. I thought Arthurs wrote because they wanted to, not for the money. Seems JK Rowling has used a lie potion here to cover this up. Rick Riordan has many books out, some for adults and some for children. The Heroes of Olympus and Percy Jackson series is really good and Rick also takes time to met his fans. I friend of mine met him the other week when Rick did a tour for Son of Neptune and he got to talk to Rick. I cant see JK Rowling doing this
God
2011-10-22 06:30:53 UTC
1. Percy Jackson! He's funny, witty, sarcastic, brave, and sweet to his friends.

2. Ah, Grover. He's funnier.

3. Annabeth, she's the daughter of Wisdom, BEAT THAT HERMIONE!

4. Kronos is more evil and scary.

5. Luke Castellan ftw.

6. The Battle of Manhattan.



7. RICK.RIORDAN. <33



I have a PJO roleplay site, I think you'd like it! Wanna join? Email me for the link! (: pipermclean98@yahoo.com
anonymous
2011-10-22 07:51:19 UTC
Huh! You make harry potter sound rubbish!

1. Harry Potter

2.Ron ( who the heck is grover?)

3.Annabeth (she's not just brave, she's strong!)

4.Voldemort

5.Luke (he seemed to be a good guy)

6. The battle of hogwarts

7. J.K Rowling (aka the author of the worlds most loved childrens book. Literally!)

And that's my opinion
anonymous
2011-10-22 05:54:05 UTC
Harry Potter
?
2011-10-22 09:15:47 UTC
1. Harry Potter

2. Ron

3. Hermione

4. Voldemort

5. Draco

6. The Battle of Hogwarts

7. JKR



smh... if you do not see the error of your ways now, you're hopeless
anonymous
2011-10-22 05:37:36 UTC
1. Percy

2. Ron

3. Hermione

4. Kronos

5. Draco

6. Battle of Hogwarts

7. J.K ROWLING~!
Jumping Sun
2011-10-22 05:31:46 UTC
Harry Potter.
?
2011-10-22 05:32:59 UTC
I'll go with harry potter. I was so excited for percy but reall dissapointed me. Story is no exciting. I just enjoy romantic interest of percy to annabeth. When i watched this i felt like director didn't get idea to make this, story is too boaring.

What I like in this movie are flying shoes and medusa.

I think it just a copy of harry potter.
Anurag C
2011-10-22 05:34:23 UTC
harry potter

grover

annabeth

voldemorth

draco

hogwarts

j.k.r
anonymous
2011-10-22 05:25:39 UTC
Do not make me get off the fence!

I cannot decide, I love them both!



Tie. Tie. Tie. Tie. Tie. Tie. Tie.
anonymous
2011-10-23 00:02:45 UTC
HARRY POTTER. period.
anonymous
2011-10-22 08:58:39 UTC
neither


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...