Question:
Harry Potter Books..Why do you like it, and why not?
RJP
2009-07-18 13:21:17 UTC
When H.P first book came out. I loved it. Not so much now..I feel like the author could've made it shorter, instead she dragged the same idea throughout 7 books,keep piling up unexplained tragic turns in Harry's life. I do understand that the story happens in magic world, but sometimes you get an impression that the story takes a weird turn and the author is trying to make sense of that by making up some magic potions and trick that doesnt make any sense. any ideas?
Twelve answers:
HP Wombat
2009-07-18 13:29:29 UTC
I completely felt that way about book 7. I was like "wand lore? where did THIS come from?" - I felt like it came out of left-field, and it was a hastily-put-together way of bringing the story together. It was like the entire story was based on coincidence, not planning or magic or anything important.



But I try to forget about it. I like 97% of stuff in Harry Potter, so I try not to let the parts that bug me get in the way of enjoying the rest. :D
HPfan7
2009-07-18 20:26:10 UTC
i get what your saying, and i kinda agree with it, but then again im glad that she dragged it out because i love the books so much and plus the rising and defeating of the darkest wizard of all time couldnt have gone down in 3 books, if you think about it. i also think that they are very well-written and creative. and for fixing a problem with a potion or trick, thats what fantasy is. in the world of harry potter, yes they can fix things that way. thats what potions are for.
anonymous
2009-07-18 20:34:56 UTC
I love the books.



at first were in a street of normal people going to work and we hear of a family who think they the best in the word. then we see a cat reading a map and the same cat is watching this man we just heard about. in town he hears about 'The Potters' we heard about the potters in the 1st page and it made them sound like trouble. at the end of the 1st chapter two wizards come and talk about this murderer and a giant in a motobike comes out of the ki with a baby. they way JK done this was great it got me hooked from page one. I wanted to know about the baby (harry) and more about him.



I feel with harry potter were with him, right from when he's waking in the morning on dudleys b-day right up to the final batle at hogworts. we see everything from harrys eyes. we know what he's feeling, when he's angry, sad ect. it makes it real. and then theys the other people, like sirius, ron, voldemort. each have they own storys. sirius - in azkaban. voldemorts history is just great
anonymous
2009-07-18 20:30:31 UTC
I think it makes sense that its seven books. for seven years at hogwarts. they even go back in the end.

And no, I think JK Rowling is just creative.

Agreed, there are some weird turns, but it all connects in the end. Which is one of the reasons I like the books so much.
AJ
2009-07-18 20:28:34 UTC
I sort of get what you are saying, but I can't agree with you. The Harry Potter series are some of the best books ever written and I will always love them.
♥dA®e †0 ße d¡ƒƒe®en†♥
2009-07-19 16:41:42 UTC
I love harry potter because the books are really good and interesting.
Lifeistough
2009-07-18 20:33:48 UTC
I don't think she was dragging it, i think every info she put in was crucial to the plot. Plus, there were alot of small drams like the s.p.e.w obsession of hermiones to amke the book lighter because its getting dark. I don't realy get why you think the book is dragging but your entitled to yuor opinion.



Reasons why I like it.....sorry if its long....



P.S IM HARDCORE harry potter fan...I love the books

these are the reasons i love the book

i copied/pasted this answer from a another question I ANSERED.

I was too tired to write the incredibly long reasons why i love the sereis so i searched through questions I ANSWERED and i found this answer i recently answered and i posted it here...sooo



i ddint want u think i copied someone elses answer its all original and mine just from anothere harry potter question.



Reasons why I like it...............



1.) The audieace is for all, not just kids. It as the books mature the further you go. Your growing up with the charaters which is is an amazing senstaion in Harry Potter. It's books for boys and girls, teens and tweens. Young adults and people with wrinkles. It captivates us all, which thanks to her writing. But again shes not the best writer, I don't think anyone in the world is a best writer. All writer have thier own technique which makes thier writing special and good.



2. It may seem childish, but only if you judge a book by it's cover. But, trust me I don't think and eleven year old can cope with deathly hallows unless he can keep up all the drama thats goiong in the books. The writing you can easily understand, I mean a kid can read it but its so complex. You ahve to pay attention to every detail to amke the whole plot work. And if you forget a tiny detail you get confused. Its a mystery kind of. Every character, detail, place even if it is the smallest and minor of things have a role in the plot in her future books. She worked REAL hard to get published ever small cryptic thing.



Which makes re-reading fun becuase you learn more stuff that happened in the book, that you Have missed in the books tyouve read in the past. I mean sheesh there no way youy remebered all the details and important little dramas going on unless you ahve a super brain lol.



3.) The plot. It's phenomanal. There is Just no plot holes. Every thing ties in togeteher. And, if you did catch a plot hole (nearly impossible) then it probably took you years. I think the plot is perfect.



4.) She doesn't just have one big plot but small dramas going on, tooo, romances, fights, jeolousy, real life situations. Humour too, romance adventure. There will be tears, in the books too.



5.) WHAT MAKES IT BELEIVABLE......welll, she creates her own scociety which comes with rules/laws/school. Criminals and politics. The world seems real with its own system just mixed with some magic and not just some magic place thats glittery and fairy like and happy with no problems (not that i hate those kind of stories i love them..lol) but there are problems in that society just like the real world have issues.She also creates this whole set of culture in this world with tis own (invented sport) and cloths and words. She creats history within her herlittle world. Wht other book did you read that have thier own givernment kind of thing.





6.) The characters are realistics with their own personality, and emotions. They also so mature within each book. But im sure alot of pple told you the characetrs are realistic.



7.) Also WHAT MAKES IT REALL. IS, everythings unexpected. YOu never know whos gonna die. Death is a big part of the book. You never know hwats goonna happen next. Its unpredictable unless you've read SPOIlers. :(

But, it does not come with a happy perfect eneding, in away it does but then again not cuz of all the sacrafices in the books too, my fave caharter dying. Its realistic i guess.



** And, The wand thing wasn't A coincidence to me, she planned out everything, the cloak harry had ever since was part of it, and in book 1 she has dumbledore give harry the cloak.



8.) you just can't stop reading, you get sucked in the world and feel like your standing write next to them. But at the end of the day /or book magicdoesnt exist. cuz its not real, but reading harry potter will create thsaht hyper excitement that makes it feel like tis real.



EDIT:

and every time u re-read the books u learn something new u didnt notice last time bcuz u cant possibly suck in every single detail or memorize it becuz the books are so thick and full of stufff (which im not complaing, i love big thick books) so every time i re-read it i learn something



for example: in book1, i never really got why harrys scar burneddd when he lookd directly at snape for the first time but if u read carefully and cuople f times aftwer re-reading it u can see that quirrl was besdie snape or something and quirrel turned his head and as a coincidence when
anonymous
2009-07-18 20:44:29 UTC
I'm sorry I must disagree. J.K. Rowling was able to come up with a whole new world from the top of her head. I know many people find older books to compare the Harry Potter series to, but reality is: it was HER idea. She came up with characters, made them like you and I, she made hundreds ! Check wikipedia, a list of all th Harry Potter characters, and you'll see how many there really are. You can't say she found all of those at the back of a book. And I know that's not what you're saying, but some people do. Also, some things may not make sense at first, but they do all add up. You're talking about potions. Lets take an example from the most recent movie; Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. Harry wins a Potion called Felix Felicis. Liquid luck. Something everyone wishes for. Rowling took ideas that many people wished for, and transfered it on to paper. This liquid luck potion came in handy for Harry later on. I think she truly had a plan, all the way through. Of course she added twists and turns, that's what makes a great story, great !

Spoilers :

In book one, Harry learns the base of his story. His parents died from the attack of the most dangerous Dark wizard, his mother died to save him, and he came face to face with the killer. He learns about his followers, the magic, his name. He learns that love can truly save someone.



In book two, Harry learns that Voldemort and himself have a connection, they can both talk to snakes. He figures out who is behind the opening of the Chamber of Secrets, Tom Riddle. Lord Voldemort. He learns more history about his foe, meats new people, like Dobby. Hence, learning about house-elves, how they are freed, etc.



In book three, Harry sees that someones closest friend can be unloyal. Harry's parents were betrayed. As the series was continued to a third book, he started to learn more about the history of his parents death. Then he meets his godfather, one adult that he can truly connect with, and possibly live with in the future. Professor Trelawney is introduced, a very important character come later books. He also meets Lupin, and learns about Fenrir Greyback.



In book four, now this one's a big one. A big tournament at Hogwarts, Harry is too young to compete in. But somehow, he was chosen. There were only supposed to be 3 but he was the 4th. Someone was planning something. Trying to get Harry killed. At the end of the novel, we learn that Voldemort has returned, in his own, proper body. Someone is killed, and once again, we see a connection between Harry and Voldemort (their two wands had a connection).



In book five, Harry is deceived by the Ministry. They are turned against him, no one wants to believe the truth. But there is a group of people that do believe him. The Order of the Phoenix. They are out to fight the Dark Lord, and they stay by Harry's side. Harry ends up losing someone dear to him, his godfather. J.K. Rowling had planned for another death, but could not bare to kill the other one off. This shows that she had a plan, it wasn't at random.



In book six, Harry goes way deaper in Voldemorts history, he learns about Horcruxes, the Dark Lord's family, his greed, his power. Once again, another death arrives, you know who it is. It was a terrible loss. One of the worse. Not only was it sad, but it made it more difficult for Harry to pursue his mission. We learn about the importance of his friends as well.



Finally, book seven, all is reveled, the end of the story. Although we find an all new plot, the 3 deathly hallows, it is obvious that it was in mind for her to do this since book one. Dumbledore had the cloak to make sure that it was truly the real one. I just don't think that she came up with this "on the spot"



I'm sorry I went on a rant, but this proves that she had a plan. She could have put it all in one, or three, but that might have made the story extremely hard to follow, and very uninteresting. Harry is a teenage, and it wasn't ALWAYS about Voldemort, though it was often, not always. He has hormones like many, he has enemies like many (Malfoy), he's a regular boy, but yet, he is not. I can't explain how much I idolize Rowling for her books. I know that a lot of people think it's nerdy, or dumb. And I think that's their opinion, no one HAS to like something. The only things I don't like, is when someone shoots me down for liking them (because I don't just like it because of the "magic", there's so much more, friendship, family, love, even the writing, i love the writing, her plan. Even if I just liked the fiction, who cares), and when people think that it was just a fluke that Rowling thought of this story. Once again, sorry I went on and on, but I hope I made my point clear :)
anonymous
2009-07-18 20:35:38 UTC
voldemort is the hardest wizard ever to find, do you really think that in the first book they were going to find him and kill him. Harry needs the training first and only dumbledore can do that
xXxKIMJxXx
2009-07-18 20:29:25 UTC
well i liked the last book it was the best of all of them the worst was the 6th one. i really got dragged into it when i saw daniel radicliff for the first time on sets. lol hez a year older than me!
i <3 books
2009-07-18 20:36:52 UTC
I only read them b/c they were on the best seller list. I think its crazy people give out huge answers for you to read lol.
?
2009-07-18 20:29:02 UTC
I like that they are dragded out because they are so great I never want them to end!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...