picky about fantasy =) that's good, some fantasy should not be considered as such. here are some suggestions:
if you like fantasy (wizards, dragons, elves, faeries, etc.):
- The Ruby Key
- Percy Jackson and the Olympians series (Sea of Monsters, The Lightning Thief, The Battle of the Labyrinth)
-The Last Apprentice series
-The Faerie Wars series (Ruler of the Realm, Faerie Lord, Faerie Wars)
- The Fire Eternal (and the whole rest of the series by Chris D'Lacy)
- The Septimus Heap series (Queste, Magyk, etc.)
- The Warrior Heir, The Wizard Heir, the Dragon Heir
- Flame
- Samurai
– Merlin’s Dragon
if you like fantasy adventure (like warriors, kingdoms, battles, etc):
- The Cry of the Icemark, Blade of Fire, Last Battle of the Icemark (trilogy)
- The Door Within, The Rise of the Wyrm Lord, The Final Storm (trilogy)
- Crystal Doors, Crystal Doors: Ocean Realm, Crystal Doors: Sky Realm (trilogy)
-The Book of the Sword, The Coming of Dragons, the Circle of Stone (Darkest Age trilogy)
- The Redwall Series
- Stoneheart, Ironhand
- The Looking Glass Wars, Seeing Redd
- Blue Flame
if you like happy/funny/romantic fantasy stories (still involving mythical creatures and humans and such):
- Dragon Slippers, Dragon Flight
- Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow (one of my favorites ever)
- The Last Dragon
- Nobody’s Princess, Nobody’s Prize
if you liked harry potter then you’ll like:
- Tapestry series (Hound of Rowan, The Second Siege)
if you like romantic books mixed with fantasy then you'll love:
- A Great and Terrible Beauty, Rebel Angels, A Sweet Far Thing
- Goddess of Yesterday
- The entire Shamer series (Shamer's Daughter, Shamer's War, Serpent's gift, etc.)
- Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow (also falls in this category)
- The Princess and the Hound
- The Host
if you like real world, teen romance then you’ll like:
- This Lullaby
- The Truth About Forever
- Someone Like You
- Dreamland
- Lock & Key
if you like real world regular teens, with hints of romance and just plain old good fun then you’ll like:
- The Alice series (one of my favorites EVER)
- I’d Tell You I Love You, But Then I’d Have To Kill You, Cross My Heart & Hope to Spy