Question:
Harry Potter movie amd book questions. Spoilers.?
Joss
2011-03-09 23:10:03 UTC
Let me know if any of these scenes aren't in the book. I saw the movie for a second time and caught stuff i missed the first time. In the movie, a boy steals from the wand shop and jumps out the window. Who is he? At first i thought it was dumbledor, but i'm not sure. Also, is the wand he takes, the one voldormort gets from dumbledor's grave in the end? - this is why i thought he was a younger dumbledoor. If it's not dumblebor then don't tell me how dumbledor got the wand. I'll find out as i make my way through the books.

Next, at the beginning, snape goes to the voldy meeting. Snape tells voldy that harry is being protected and tells him when they're going to move harry to a safe house on a certain date. Someone interrupts to say he heard differently and gives a different date. Voldy eventually picks the right date. Is this the date snape gave him? Just this question, no more details or spoilers.

Harry, ron, hermoine teleport by holding hands. What is this spell and in what book do they learn it? Or how are they able to do it?

In the scene when harry visits his birthplace, does he realize he and that 'lady' are talking parsle tongue? The lady that's actually a snake. I'm not sure he would have gone along with it had he known. I know in the second book, harry doesn't realize it.

Lastly, regarding the deathly hallows object - the cloak, stone, and wand - is the stone the philosopher's stone and the cloak harry's invisibility cloak? Just a yes or know. Complete guess on my part.

BQ: if you saw the movie, which is your fav. Part? Mine is the begining when they 'polymorph' into harry and start being attacked by death eaters.

BQ2: what's your fav HP movie? Mine is The Half-Blood Prince, but deathly hallows 1 is a close second.

Q3: what's your fav book in the series?
Three answers:
natlee
2011-03-09 23:23:28 UTC
First, that is not Dumbledore. You will find out who he is later on (I don't want to spoil it for you). And the wand that he takes is the one in Dumbledore's grave.



Next, Voldemort does pick Snape's date.



Wizards can "teleport" once they reach their fifth year, I believe. It's not a spell, and it's called apparating. All wizards can do it, but they don't learn how to do it until they reach a certain age. The book explains how they learned how to apparate.



Harry does not realize that him and the old lady are speaking parsletongue, just like in the second book.



Lastly, you are spoiling the movie for yourself, but yes that is true.



My favorite part was probably when Ron came back to Harry and Hermione. I love Ron and Hermione being together, so I thought that was really sweet!



My favorite movie is the newest one. I thought it was really cool, and I'm so excited for the second part!



My favorite book in the series is also the last book. J.K. Rowling is an amazing writer, so all the books were great, but I just loved the last one because it explained everything and brought all the books together.



Hope this helps! Accio July 15!!!!
samantha91a
2011-03-10 07:26:49 UTC
I tried to be as vague as possible in my answers so as not to give anything away:



1. The boy stealing the wand is not Dumbledore, but telling you who it is would tell you how Dumbledore got the wand, so I won't. Yes, it is the same wand



2. Yes, it is the date Snape gave him.



3. They are using apparation - specifically, side-along apparation. The skill is covered in Half Blood Prince.



4.He doesn't realize about the Parseltongue until afterwards (Hermione realizes in the book)



5. With the stone and the cloak, you're half right (no and yes). BUT the actual stone has been mentioned in a previous book/movie.



BQ: My favorite part of the movie was when Harry and Hermione started dancing together in the tent. A lot of people I know hated that scene, but I thought it showed how dearly two people could care about each other without being romantically involved. The whole episode with Ron's leaving was well done. It was interesting to see the different bonds Harry has with his best friends and how he handles the problems they face with each of them.



BQ2: Deathly Hallows Part 1



BQ3: Deathly Hallows, followed by Order of the Phoenix.
pancake
2011-03-10 07:18:35 UTC
The boy that steals the wand is Grindelwald. He was good friends with Dumbledore when they were teenagers, then Grindelwald turned bad, Dumbledore defeated him, and Dumbledore took the wand. That wand is the elder wand, it is one of the deathly hallows. It gets passed to its next master by defeating the current master of the wand. Voldemort steals it from the grave because he thinks that obtaining it will give him its powers. This is incorrect, he could only be the master of the wand if he'd killed Dumbledore.



Snape killed Dumbledore, but only because Dumbledore asked him to. Therefore, Snape didn't DEFEAT Dumbledore, and the last person to attack Dumbledore was actually Draco Malfoy on the tower. So at the end of the first half of the seventh movie, Draco is still the master.



Yes, Snape, on Dumbledore's orders, gave the right date to Voldemort. This was to convince Voldemort that Snape still works only for Voldemort. Dumbledore thought that the aurors/Harry, Ron, Hermione could handle getting out of Privet Drive alive.



When they teleport, they're apparating. Hermione performs the spell, thinks of the place she wants to go, and casts the spell. She can take Harry and Ron with her using side-along apparation. Just means they come along if they're touching her.



Harry doesn't realise when he's talking parseltongue. That's why the snake (Nagini) took him upstairs where Hermione couldn't hear.



The stone is not the philosophers stone, that was destroyed. The stone was in that ring that Dumbledore obtained (the one that cursed and blackened his hand).



Best movie has to be number three. Best book also has to be number three. And the best part of the movie is the scene with Cormac McLaggen on the train because he's HOT.



Sorry if you didn't want the spoilers, but now it all makes sense to you, right?


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...