Question:
ANNABEL LEE by E. A. Poe (1849)?
Dee
2007-04-06 08:31:05 UTC
Hi I really need anyone who knows about poetry to answer this. I have a school project and I need at least 3 peoples
opinion. Thanks so much ahead of time <3!
What can you infer from the poem about Poe's attitude toward death? Is it a Christian one? Does he succeed in making you, the reader, feel as he does? Does his meter help him or hinder him in establishing the poem's mood? Why?
Seven answers:
Elven
2007-04-06 08:52:41 UTC
His attitude toward death seems to be that it can be sudden, and vengeful, on a whim of higher beings. However, it also seems that he realizes that death is just another step, and will not separate him forever from those who have passed on. It has Christian elements to it, but is not a cannon belief. Poe is very sucessful in making the reader feel like him. The meter helps the flow of the poem, and with it the mood.
Nathan D
2007-04-06 09:05:42 UTC
The speaker (not necessarily Poe) has seemingly forsaken all things and attends Annabel Lee's tomb. His attitude is that of denial. He feels that not even death can keep him from loving her, and she him.



I don't know what is supposed to be Christian or un-Christian about this attitude. I am inclined to say no, because Christians have a "She's in a better place" kind of attitude when it comes to death. The afterlife is positive for loving people and torturous for horrible people. This doesn't seem to point to any kind of afterlife at all.



No. He does not succeed in making me feel as he does. I have lost my fair share of Annabel Lee's and although I do not deny death as an end to love, I certainly opt to continue living.



His meter, I think, is traditionally Poe and is what makes this one of many poems that people still enjoy reading. His meter produces a light, sing-songy rhythm that makes this seem almost fantastical. It is not a traditionally macabre death poem and I think it probably does for Poe what he expects of it, which makes him an effective poet.
PJ
2007-04-06 09:33:12 UTC
Written in 1849, "Annabel Lee" was published the same year, and actually two days after Poe's death on October 7. The poem appeared in two newspapers, the Richmond Examiner and the New York Tribune, and then in the 1850 edition of The Works of the Late Edgar Allan Poe. The poem has since become one of Poe's most popular works.



Using a melodious narrative form and relying heavily on meter to establish the rhythm of the repetitive phrasing, the speaker laments the death, many years ago, of his beloved young bride Annabel Lee - a symbol for Poe's real wife, Virginia, who died of tuberculosis early in their marriage. His loss moves him to state that envious angels caused the girl's death to "dissever" (separate) the young married couple. He tells briefly of her funeral and entombment "in her sepulchre ... by the sea." The narrator then reveals that he has been unable to accept their separation. Many suggest that the last stanza is a foreshadowing of Poe's death and that he anticipates joining her. The idea of being reunited with his love would lead me to believe that Poe held a somewhat traditional Christian view of death - that of meeting up with loved ones in heaven. The mention of angels and demons also seems to demonstrate some measure of belief in the Christian attitude toward death.



Use of repetitive phrasing and meter is a storetelling technique designed to make the reader/listener remember the words and the story. It does, indeed, help establish the mood as does the choice of words - sepulchre rather than grave, for instance.



As for relating to the narrator, that is up to each reader. For me, personally, this poem provides insight into his thoughts and emotions but doesn't "put me in the narrator's shoes."



Good luck with your project.
anonymous
2007-04-06 08:48:39 UTC
I have read Poe's Complete Tales and Poems. Though I believe he has underlying Christian beliefs, he has twisted them to the extremes of morbidity and macabre. He let the death of his wife overwhelm his every thought and whim. He does not succeed in making me think as he does, rather in making me understand how he thinks. Definately the meter helps him establish the mood. I would highly reccommend reading many of his stories. (My favorite is The Pit and the Pendulum.) Have a dictionary nearby; he has a tremendous vocabulary.
dlfinefrock
2007-04-09 11:21:30 UTC
his attitude towards death is that he resends it and finds it as a vengful act. I don't think this is a Christian viewpoint. I don't really share his view on this.

I think the meter is one of the things that makes this poem great. The reader is drawn through the poem.
anonymous
2007-04-06 09:08:06 UTC
i think he was really angry and went crazy so much because he loved her a lot. when i'm angry i might blame other people like he blamed the angels. he went against everything even his religion to his devoted love of his wife. and yes i felt what he felt because we feel that anger that he felt and that overwhelming love and at the same time the overwhelming hate, sadness for the death of his wife.
anonymous
2007-04-06 08:35:50 UTC
Do your own homework.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...