Question:
To authors only please, writing question?
stacie
2010-02-21 09:30:25 UTC
Okay, I think I may know the answer to this already, but I'd like to hear your thoughts. Do you have to read a lot of different authors works to be able to write if you know the genre you would like to write in. I'm not very interested in other books, I've tryied reading them and find myself very bored. I think the only book I read that completely tore me apart was "Dear John" by Nicholas Sparks. I went out and bought his book along with several others from different authors, but I just can't seem to get into it. I bought an idiots guide to writing a novel and all the questions it askes, I have no Idea how to answer. I feel pretty studpid. In high school I was a different person back then, a partier, and don't even remember reading shakespear. So I guess should I just give this dream up knowing that my spelling, grammar, and structure suck and just write for fun, or are there those rare cases? I'm an educated person. I have my BA in special education k-12 and my associates degree in Registered nursing. I've done several jobs in my life, but I feel like I would really like to write. I am new to reading, and have become obsessed with it with a certain genre, but I really don't know what to do? I've wrote a few scenes in which I was very embarrased to show my husband, but I did. The scenes were for two different stories i had in my head and they were two different genres. He liked the one from the genre that I like to read, and not so much the other one. But to be honest, I liked the other one more. I can picture scenes in my head and I feel compeled to write them down. It drives me crazy if i don't write them down and get them out of my head. It happened one night and I did not right it down and was up for 3 hours unable to sleep. So what is your advice. I would really appreciate it.
Ten answers:
Joss
2010-02-21 10:48:56 UTC
According to Stephen King and many other writers, you need to read as much as you can. If you don't like to read then you're not going to become an author. It's essential. Yes, reading helps with grammar, spelling, punctuation, and vocabulary. It also helps with learning literary and genre elements, how to develop characters and plots, and other essential things you'll need to know when writing a novel. It's there before your eyes, in novel form, and most likely done successfully. You learn the different writing styles that authors use. You can study how they caught the reader's attention. You learn how they keep suspense in a page-turning novel. You also learn what has been done a million times over in that genre and try not to repeat it because it'll make your novel unoriginal. It also gives you the chance to differentiate your novel from everything else on the shelf, so that you have a better chance of being published.



You've probably been out of school for a while, so go to the library or bookstore and pick up grammar book, thesaurus, and dictionary. I haven't had an English class in years, since I was a freshman in college, so I have a grammar book by my side. Stephen King says in his book On Writing that the only writing book that's good enough for him to recommend is Strunk and White's Elements of Style. You can buy the updated version at the bookstore and you can view the public domain version here: http://www.bartleby.com/141/



My advice is to keep writing. That's how you get better. The thing that sets you apart from others on Answers is that you know when your writing stink, so that leaves way for you to improve. There are many teens who post their work here to think it's the best thing every written, all the while ignoring all the grammar issues and misspellings. They're disillusioned and it'll take them a while to get better since they don't see anything to improve in their writing. You, on the other hand, can greatly improve because you recognize that your writing isn't perfect and can be better. That's a good thing. This is what most writers have to endure during their first forays into writing. It's common and your case isn't special. Buy some how-to books, join so writing forums, and start researching how to write a novel. The more you write then the more you'll improve. After you've finished editing one novel then start another one and keep writing. Most published authors start out writing crap before they begin writing publishable material. It's part of the learning process, and you need to go through those stages before you can master the skill.



You're new to reading, so continue reading and read as much as you can. I didn't start reading regularly until the last two years of high school. Over the years, I cut down on how much I read, but I've picked it back up. Read a few classics. I recommend Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austin, if you like romance. She has some complex characters and you can analyze how she made them so complex and use that to help develop your character. Analyze the books you read and study how the authors handled different elements within it. A good exercise to get you started: read some books and then copy the first two chapters of them. This will help with writing style and help you learn some of the elements so that you can duplicate them with your own novel. Once you get the hang of it then you'll be able to develop your own style of writing and implement those elements effectively. Keep in mind that when giving work to family and friends that it's subjective. If someone doesn't like to read romance and you wrote romance, then they might not like it. So give it to people who like reading the genre you write. Good luck.



No, hooranim is WRONG about publishers not caring about grammar. I take that he hasn't done his publishing research? I've seen literary agents say they've rejected people because their work is full of bad grammar and/or misspellings. Don't embarrass yourself like that by sending off work with basic errors. Yes, agents have even told stories of how they've turned down great storylines because of bad writing. Bad grammar is a sign of weak writing, is what I've learned. Also, publishers aren't going to go around correcting your work like your high school English teacher would. Your work needs to be 95% publishable before a publisher will even buy it. If you need too many edits and corrections then they'll reject it, no matter how great your plot/concept is. You'll get all kinds of bad and erroneous info from Answers, and most of it comes from teens who can't write to save their lives, and who are just guessing or making assumption about the industry. I've actually done my homework - months of research - because I'm serious about trying to get published. You also need to do your research so you can discriminate between the good and bad info.
Marli
2010-02-24 12:50:03 UTC
You don't have to read a lot of authors' works to write a story. If you've got an idea, go for it. It's your story. You don't have to write like Nicholas Sparks. Write like yourself - the best you can.



But it helps a lot to read as many different authors' works as you can. If Nicholas Sparks turns on your creative juices to the max, read him. Read others in the same genre. (Those authors you see on the back cover praising Nick's book for a start.) One wonderful thing about borrowing a selection from a public library: you don't have to keep what you don't want, and you haven't lost any money by the experiment. The ones that bored you: was it the plotting that bored you? The characters? The setting? Jot down why. If you were the author of that boring book, how would you change it? That exercise might give you ideas for your own stories.



The Idiot's Guide? I suggest keeping it with you for a while, and re-read a chapter when you have a little spare time. You don't have to answer the questions right off - and there's no 'right' answer. The questions are there to make you think, to build up your creative muscles. Believe me, I hate to think, but we think all the time. There is also no 'right' manual how to write. Go to the start of the 800's in the library and check out whatever how to write books that catch your attention. You'll find that the advice is not exactly the same.



Don't give up your dream. Write for fun. Nothing wrong with that. You're not obliged to publish. In fact, if you've been bitten so hard that you are compelled to write, then you've got to write to stay sane. Polish up your stories until you think they're ready to go to a publisher or agent. Remember that authors go through at least two drafts of every story they submit - and even when you submit it to a publisher or to a writing workshop, you'll cringe and think your work is garbage. Most writers think that. Read books about writers - most writers say that they wish their early work wasn't available ... it's so bad.



As for spelling and grammar: When you write your first draft, don't let them matter. Just get down what you see, hear, feel inside your head. The story is FIRST PRIORITY. Ignore your internal critic and editor. Tell the voice in your head, "You'll get your chance when it's done." Get it written and finished. Then let it rest a day or two. Then read it over. Correct what spelling and other errors you see. Get someone you trust to read it for spelling, grammar and punctuation if you don't feel confident about your own skills. [If you can, take an evening course in English grammar and composition at your school or college. A lot of bright adults take remedial English.] Cut and paste and rearrange and add new chapters - do whatever makes your vision as a writer clearer to you as a reader.



Last bit of advice. Take it easy. Enjoy the thrill of composition. Don't worry if your first story isn't published. You've written it. There it is in concrete form. You can rewrite it, re-submit it, wait for the trend to go its way. Give it to your children as a 'family keepsake'. It's not dead in the womb, which is where it would have been if you had not written it. You can write a second story. A third.
S.K.
2010-02-21 10:34:33 UTC
Every person who reads likes some kinds of books better than others. We have tastes, and they're all valid.



As a writer, you serve yourself well to read extensively in the genre in which you write, and a sampling of the best of other genres as well. Why? Because you need to know what's happening in your own genre which is different and new and will potentially affect your ability to sell your work, and because a well-rounded writer reads without limitations.



Even if what you love is westerns, I guarantee you'll enjoy the best sci-fi, thriller, and romance. If you don't get into a particular book, feel free to set it aside--but pick up something else in the same genre. Seek reviews and recommendations to help you refine your tastes. It's like movies--some critics like what you do, and some don't.



If you really want to write, then by all means write. I urge you not to take on a novel as a first project, but if you ignore that advice (which you're free to do, of course), at least have a detailed plan for the whole thing complete before you begin the writing.
2010-02-21 09:44:42 UTC
There's nothing wrong with liking one genre more than another. I would suggest reading other authors and other genres so that you can learn from a wider base of writing styles, but this isn't absolutely vital to learning how to write. If you're interested in one genre then read that as much as you can. If you feel weak in grammar and what not then take a class to strengthen those weaknesses. You shouldn't give up because of them. Since you're new to reading, give yourself time to explore what's out there. It's natural to be embarrassed to show your work whether you've been writing for forever or only a day. Apiece of writing is very intimate and a critique of it feels like a critique of us.



I would suggest finding a writing class for the technical aspects of writing. Grammar, structure, and whatnot. And finding a class or writing group to have people read over and edit your work. Through these process you will become a stronger, more confident writer. A writing group will point out inconsistencies with the story itself and help you strengthen it.
aileen
2016-05-31 07:10:03 UTC
I have never written to an author but I imagine, like anybody else, some are better at sending responses than others. I suppose you have to look at it from their point of view. If you were a successful author who received hundreds of letters a week, as much as you would appreciate the fan support and feedback, would you be able to put aside a few hours each day to send a brief "thank you for writing" response back to them? If I were a published, successful author, I'm not sure I could. I might try at first, but I think over time I would feel overwhelmed and start to slack off. I would feel bad about it, but it wouldn't change my actions.
2010-02-21 11:31:00 UTC
You should certainly have read lots of different authors in the genre you are trying to write in before you set your heart on getting something published.



I mean...you are a new reader and writer. It's perfectly normal for you just to be writing odd scenes at the moment. You wouldn't expect to be writing a whole novel, any more than a new skater would be performing a whole program. They'd be working on single elements and basic technique. Just like you are. The standard benchline number is that most people write about a million words of fiction before they get to a publishable standard. You probably won't be the exception.



You don't have to read the whole of Shakespeare. But it's a good idea to look at what it is people like about his work. Put-down lines? Romance? Descriptions? Characters?



I'd go for a middle road. Write for fun. If you carry on enjoying it, you'll carry on improving, and at some point your dream will become practical. If you _don't_ carry on enjoying it, it won't last as your dream anyway, so why worry about it?
2010-02-21 10:21:59 UTC
1. find an author you like, and read his/her books. (I am addicted to Stephen King, but that is waning) I have a few by James Mitchener and I think he is next on the list. Staying with one author might help you create "your style".

2. Instead of like/dislike, get constructive criticism.

3. classify your story thoughts; give them names or numbers. Put in as much as you can about each then file it away for future reference. Numbering each plot works the best for me. But now I am seeing how I can combine plots and characters.

4. When you are at a dead end, make a quick list of the characters needed for the story , then go back and fill in their characteristics; traits. The idea here is to brainstorm to get all the characters needed for a story and not to get hung up on a specific one. ( Ithink it is easier to get rid of too many characters, maybe even kill one off, rather than try to add one later on. )

5. About 4 years ago I started on a plot about a early thirties married couple living in a suburb of Lowell Mass. in the early part of the story, the couple walked into the a hallway of their home, embraced, then looked at me and said "Well, now what do we do?" I knew I was on to something. The story is at about 5,000 words and I keep adding more parts to it. (they are being chased by the KGB)

6. Tell your story as if you were telling a friend. That might make it easier to explain.

7. Join a writers groupthesaurushat inspires you?Try keeping a good dictionary and thesarus with in arms reach when you are writing.

8. Maps. Draw a map of the town or area your story is in. A floor plan if it is in a house.

9. Do an outline. This should help to move the story forward, by putting things in perpective.

I hope I helped but I think I went over board.
2010-02-21 09:49:16 UTC
no reading isnt neccessary to writing your own piece of writing but you said you liked dear john trying reading more of that that might help you out and movies and tv shows might help you out too like dear john the move try that and maybe if your so worried buy a couple of writing books and take a creative writing course and start doing some writing activities and dont back down focus and write



~~~Christmas Gal~~~
nini
2010-02-21 09:35:55 UTC
You sound like you got the bug. Give it a try! But do try to read, even if it's not the same genre you write in.



aand use paragraphs! ;)
hooranimation
2010-02-21 10:02:43 UTC
Writing is not about grammar.The publisher do it for you. It's about story and character. Congratulation, you are ready to writing. write whatever you want. But you must have a plot of your subject and your character. If you just want write short stories you just need to explain your character in the way it's thinking. you must have a basic idea just in "one sentence" like this: women never tire of their children. You absolutely must have that sentence if you have not your story can't get explained.

If you have any question. you can mail me


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...