Question:
is it good to readcliff notes beforeyou read shakespeare or does it take away from the expierience?
ralph
2006-02-03 16:23:54 UTC
is it good to readcliff notes beforeyou read shakespeare or does it take away from the expierience?
Seven answers:
LeMat
2006-02-04 14:26:16 UTC
The quick answer: I'd read the Shakespeare first. Cliff's Notes will tell you "Lear appears on stage with dead Cordelia in his arms, yelling," whereas Shakespeare will lead up to such an impacting moment with grace, suspense, and solemnity.



What I would advise you to do if you need some help with the language, though, is to get yourself an edition of the Shakespeare play you're interested in that has significant commentary. There are dozens of different editions of each play out there, and many will 'sum up' what is happening in a scene either in the margins of the text or in the introduction to each new scene. It will be up to you to decide what level of editorial assistance you might need, whether you're brand-new to Early Modern English and you'll look for a high school edition of the play (such as Macmillan or Penguin), undergraduate (Norton or Broadview), or graduate (Oxford, New Cambridge, Arden).



MOST IMPORTANTLY, though, DON'T TRUST the Cliff's/Coles' Notes for assignments! Most of the time, they will get the plot of the play down correctly, but if there were any way to make what Shakespeare was thinking any clearer, he would have written it differently. In sticking to the Coles' Notes, you will miss out on a lot of the double-meanings, symbols and images that make Shakespeare as famous as he is. I read over the Hamlet notes for his "to be, or not to be" soliloquy recently, and there were volumes of meaning that a teacher would hope you'd pick up on that were completely absent from the translation. It told you literally what Hamlet's words MEANT, but not what he was really saying.
Stepheyne
2006-02-03 16:31:47 UTC
I would read them at the same time. Shakespeare can be kind of garbled at times and the cliff notes can help you make sure you understand what you just read. I definitely would NOT read them beforehand. It will take away from the reading of Shakespeare and you may get frustrated trying to figure out why Shakespeare can't just be in plain English and explain it the way the cliff notes are! lol Reading the original story is much better than the abridged version.
kumquatbaby
2006-02-03 16:31:10 UTC
The only way to read Shakespear is to read it like it would be performed in the theater b/c that is what it was meant for. If you are able to read it out loud and with enthusiasm w/o feeling like a dork, that would probably be the best way. O.K., so I'm rambling...but I think you get the point.(Avoid the cliff notes if you can stand it)
jude89
2006-02-04 13:54:28 UTC
When I studied Shakespeare, I read them together. First, I would try to read the actual play, then if I could not understand it, I would read the notes. Once I understood it, I re-read it without the notes and I enjoyed it.
?
2016-05-20 16:15:08 UTC
he would be the greatest person ever! i am so pro-Kira! he HAS good intentions. killing all the criminals is a GOOD thing. i mean, in the beginning, he only killed the truly evil people who have taken some lives themselves. i understand that he went kinda crazy [i would've too] but overall, Kira rocks! psh, Misa practically ASKS to be used anyway. Kira is justice ^^ if i had a Death Note, i'd totally be the next Kira!
kari
2006-02-03 16:31:05 UTC
cliffnotes leave out a lot of details. You wont know direct quotes or a lot of what is going on. read the text first, and then the cliffnotes to help you summarize it and remember.
VagisilWipes
2006-02-03 16:27:25 UTC
If reading for pleasure, yes. If reading for regurgitation on a test, no.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...